Carlson leads his Washington team with a +12 +/- rating. Washington has been using John Carlson and Karl Alzner as their number one shutdown defensive line. It is Carlson that is carrying the load on this line. Alzner has spent the last two seasons splitting his time between the AHL and NHL and has not shown the same NHL skillset as Carlson.--The Puck Stops Here, Kuklas Korner.
John Carlson is playing a significant defensive role and he is doing it very well. He is carrying a lesser defence partner as he does this. He is also putting up a respectable offensive showing. This makes John Carlson the leading rookie this season. He should be considered the Calder Trophy leader at this point, but his lack of a high point total has largely left him overlooked.
There are two things being said here: one, that John Carlson is a stud (but we already knew that). The other is that perhaps Karl Alzner is a bit in over his head at this point. That's what Corsi indicates: before being paired with Alzner (this season), Carlson was still handling the toughs and had a Corsi Rel close to ten. Since being paired with Alzner, Carlson's Corsi Rel has fallen into the neighborhood of five, and Alzner has been hovering around zero or in low positives all along. And that's when Alzner has been getting the better teammates by Corsi Rel QoC (or at least better-performing teammates). It certainly seems like Puck Stops Here was right.
But that's okay.